Ladies Kennel Association 2005 |
Collie (Smooth) |
Judge:
Mr N J Smith
|
Dog CC : 3630 Mrs P J EVANS Manordeifi Smart Guy at Southcombe Res Dog CC : 3636 Mrs I M G GRIFFITHS Alopex Highland Fling Bitch CC : 3651 Miss S J WHITTINGHAM Southcombe Society Girl Res Bitch CC : 3623 Mrs E & Ms C BULLION Foxearth Flame of Love at Ostarain Best Puppy : 3624 Mrs J BURGESS Lilymead Appanchi Best Veteran : BEST OF BREED : 3630 Mrs P J EVANS Manordeifi Smart Guy at Southcombe Class 471 PD (1 Entries) Abs: 0 1st: 3647 Mr & Mrs B TRUNDLEY Lilymead Agamennon TAF 2nd: 3rd: Res: VHC: Class 472 JD (2 Entries) Abs: 1 1st: 3631 Mrs D A & Miss F L FORBES Pelghart Pied Piper 2nd: 3rd: Res: VHC: Class 473 PGD (5 Entries) Abs: 1 1st: 3649 Mrs D WALLIS Norfield Soul Mate 2nd: 3629 Miss L EKE Foxearth Fred Perry 3rd: 3622 Miss D ARKSEY Norfield Checkmate Res: 3633 Mr A & Mrs S A FULWOOD Darsign Minstrel Blue VHC: Class 474 LD (4 Entries) Abs: 0 1st: 3630 Mrs P J EVANS Manordeifi Smart Guy at Southcombe 2nd: 3636 Mrs I M G GRIFFITHS Alopex Highland Fling 3rd: 3638 Mr T & Mrs B HAYWARD Foxearth French'y Res: 3622 Miss D ARKSEY Norfield Checkmate VHC: Class 475 OD (2 Entries) Abs: 1 1st: WHD WITHHELD 2nd: 3622 Miss D ARKSEY Norfield Checkmate 3rd: Res: VHC: Class 476 PB (4 Entries) Abs: 1 1st: 3624 Mrs J BURGESS Lilymead Appanchi 2nd: 3648 Mr & Mrs B TRUNDLEY Lilymead Alisia TAF 3rd: 3634 Mrs H R GIBSON Pelghart Perhaps Perhaps Res: VHC: Class 477 JB (3 Entries) Abs: 0 1st: 3626 Mrs K E COATES Starlight Spirit at Pencloda 2nd: 3635 Mrs H R GIBSON Pelghart Pure Gold 3rd: Res: VHC: Class 478 PGB (5 Entries) Abs: 1 1st: 3623 Mrs E & Ms C BULLION Foxearth Flame of Love at Ostarain 2nd: 3645 Ms H TAYLOR Snuggletooth Fillys Fancy Among Trageeda 3rd: 3641 Miss D J MOORES Manordeifi Party Doll Res: 3644 Mrs P & Miss J SEWELL Foxearth Farris via Lewarne VHC: Class 479 LB (5 Entries) Abs: 1 1st: 3651 Miss S J WHITTINGHAM Southcombe Society Girl 2nd: 3642 Mrs D K & Miss C ROBINSON Hilltarn Valentine JW 3rd: 3645 Ms H TAYLOR Snuggletooth Fillys Fancy Among Trageeda Res: 3625 Mr & Mrs S BURTON Glencorrie Begorgeous VHC: Class 480 OB (3 Entries) Abs: 1 1st: 3640 Mrs J MACGREGOR Ch Southcombe Sophisticate at Rowvale 2nd: 3643 Mrs D K & Miss C ROBINSON Ch Southcombe Sweet as a Nut 3rd: Res: VHC: |
As with all breeds entries are dropping,
but I find it concerning that the quality is dropping also. 15-20 years ago the
ring was fully of quality exhibits and to qualify for Cruft’s was an
achievement. Sadly today that is not the case, you can qualify by simply turning
up. Although it is inevitable that numbers will decrease, we must strive to
maintain the quality. Type and size is very mixed, the influence of foreign
blood seems to have improved some areas, but weakened others. The tail carriage
on Smooth’s on the whole used to be good, but many exhibits today were
unacceptable or border line. The bitches today were of better quality, some of
which on another day could get top honours, but I struggled to find many quality
males. Hopefully they are at home?
PD (1,0). 1 TrundleyB4s Lilymead Agamennon b/m. Just 6 months and very
promising. Head very clean for age. Nice rounded muzzle and flat back skull.
Ears need to rise. Good angulation front and rear. Tailset good. Needs more
ringcraft to improve on the move.
JD (2,1). 1 Forbes’ Pelghart Pied Piper. Nice size, with good clean head,
flat back skull. Ears well set, but flying slightly. Could do with more weight.
Coat black, but white markings exceed withers, and onto rib cage. Well off for
bone and good rear angulation. Tailed just acceptable. Movement ok.
PGD (5,1). 1 Wallis’ Norfield Soul Mate. Nice up to size s/w with a good
overall balance and shape. Masculine clean head. Moved ok but tail rather high.
2 Eke’s Foxearth Fred Perry. This very smart tri caught my eye the moment he
entered the ring. Very well balanced throughout. Head handles very well. Clean
cheeks, sweet dark eye of correct shape and good flat back skull. Ample bone,
level top line, Well set tail. Moved well. If only his ears were not flying he
would have challenged for top honours. 3 Arksey’s Norfield Checkmate.
LD (4,0). 1 Evans’ Manordeifi Smart Guy at Southcombe. There is not much to
dislike about this 2 yrs old s/w. Medium sized and completely balanced. Head of
good length and proportions. Rounded muzzle, filling in well as he matures.
Sweetest obliquely set eye, very well balanced and flat backskull. Good length
of neck leading to very well placed shoulders. Well angulated straight front.
Level top line, back of good length, with well rounded croup and solid rear.
Stood and showed to perfection, and his forte was his effortless movement.
Pleased to award him DCC & BOB, and pleased to learn that this was his crowning
CC. 2 Griffiths Alopex Highland Fling. Awarded this very smart tri best puppy
the last time I judged. He is a nice size and is maturing well. Head of good
balance with well placed ears. Body of good proportions and angulated well fore
and aft. Ample bone and well set tail. As with all dogs from this kennel and the
CC winning kennel, movement was excellent. RCC. 3 Haywards Foxearth French’y. OD
(2,1). 1 WHD. 2 Arksey’s Norfield Checkmate Brother to PG winner and placed
lower down in PG & L. Well grown s/w, too immature for open. Strong head
pattern. Good bone, well made front and rib cage. Coat of very good texture but
very open. Moved ok, but tail carried too high. Handled well.
PB (4,1). 1 Burgess’ Lilymead Appanchi. Just 6 mths, but very promising
tri. Beautiful over all shape and balance. Sweetest of heads, with dark eye.
Ears well set, but just tending to fly. Very clean cheeks and good back skull.
Nice length of neck which she used well. Level top line, well set tail. Still
erratic on the move. Lovely out going disposition. BP. 2 Trundley’s Lilymead
Alisia 3rd puppy from this same litter, and many of the same point apply. Not
quite the head quality of her sister, slightly more open coated. but still very
promising. Nice size and shape. Very out going, but needs to settle on the move.
3 Gibsons Pelghart Perhaps Perhaps.
JB (3,1). 1 Coates Starlight Spirit at Pencloda. Sweet headed blue, very
well balanced throughout. Good level top line, well made front and rear which
produced excellent movement. 2 Gibson’s Pelghart Pure Gold, s/w too fine in
muzzle for me, and not the sweetness of 1. Good flat back skull with well set
and used ears. Nice front angulations and level top line. Rear angulations also
good. Tight coat. Moved well, tail just acceptable.
PGB (5,1). Hardest class of the days. 4 bitches that all had good qualities
and could easily swap places on another day. 1 Bullion’s Foxearth Flame of Love
at Ostarain. Have admired and judged this very pretty tri before. Very balanced
throughout, and for me a perfect size. Her head is very clean and she has the
sweetest dark eyes. Flat back skull, ears well set are used. Ample neck leading
to good shoulders. Beautifully rounded croup and well set tail. Carrying too
much weight which effected her movement, which nearly cost her, but I could not
get past her overall qualities and breed type. RCC. 2 Taylor’s Snuggletooth
Fillys Fancy among Trageeda. Very well present tri, in top condition. Not quite
as good in eye as one but. Body of good shape and balance. Jet black coat of
good texture. A pity she was determined to play her handler up on the move. 3
Moores’ Manordeifi Party Doll.
LB (5,1). 1 Whittingham’s Southcombe Society Girl. I have admired this
very smart tri since I first set eyes on her over a year ago, and was pleased to
have the opportunity to judge her. She has the classic smooth shape that was in
abundance when I first entered the breed, that is sadly lacking today. Her head
is very clean and balanced and of good length. Eye well placed, but could be
darker to give a sweeter expression. Ears well set and used. Very good length of
neck., leading to good shoulders, level top line and nicely rounded croup. Tail
well set. Movement ok, but tending to look at handler rather then concentrating
on where she was going. This cost her the challenge for BOB, but as with the
dog, this was her crowning CC. 2 Robinsons Hilltarn Valentine JW. Another very
nice tri, this time a more workmanlike type, and not quite the femininity of 1,
being very solid through out, with a slightly stronger head pattern than the
first. Strong muzzle, good under jaw. Level back skull, ears well set and used.
Strong neck and once again good top line. Ample bone, good ribbing. Adequate
angulations fore and aft. Jacket of good texture, but could be tighter. moved
very well. 3 Taylors Snuggletooth. FF among T.
OB (3,1). 1 Macgregor’s Ch Southcombe Sophisticate at Rowvale. Up to size
stylish tri, presented in immaculate condition as always from this kennel. Head
handles well, very well rounded muzzle, and flat back skull. Nice eye, well used
ears. Strong neck and very good shoulders. Ample bone and ribbing. Nice level
and length of back, rounded croup and well angulated rear. Tail very well set.
Moved well going away, but tending to roll on the front. 2 Robinson’s Ch.
Southcombe Sweet as a Nut. 4 yrs s/w that I have done well in the past. Today
though she did not have the same sparkle or spring in her step. Nice overall
size and shape, Head of good length, clean cheeks, neat well used ears. Eye
could be sweeter. Very well made body, being very well angulated at all
quarters. Correct coat of good texture. Moved and handled well.
Nick Smith